ACDB  Log In
Search

READ ONLY MODE IS ACTIVATED

Post Reply
ACDB Forums :: Anime Characters Database :: Site Discussion
Posted 14 year(s) ago Character Roles # 7415

Rei
ダメ人間

Rei Avatar
10 Stars
Head Admin
Joined on 05-24-07
Posts 2102

anonymous17 asked recently for more Roles, but picking the right ones to add is proving not so easy!

Protagonist
Antagonist
Protagonist's Nakama
Antagonist's Nakama
Supporting
Sub
Extra
unset

There was Tritagonist and Deuteragonist for a short while, but doesn't really apply to every series, and the words need a Wiki entry to make sense.


I think for most short series, this should be enough. Other longer running series, where each arc has a new Antagonist ... I'm not sure if there's some way we could do better.


So are Sub Characters and Supporting Characters more or less the same thing? Any distinction we could make?

As for Nakama... every otaku should know that word! ;-) But if someone wants to argue for Allies/Friends instead of Nakama, I'll change it.

[ Edited Jul 11, 2011 ]
[Image]

私は日本語を少し読むと書くをできます。あなたも?

[Image]
Top PM Rei
Posted 14 year(s) ago Re: # 7416

EatsSweets
Page of Void

EatsSweets Avatar
2 Stars

Joined on 05-22-11
Posts 107

Using Nakama instead of friends is fine.
As for sub and supporting characters I have no idea if they're the same or if they're different.
Maybe sub character means secondary character? No clue. I looked up supporting character and the results I got were:
A supporting character is a character of a book, play, video game, movie, television or radio show other form of storytelling usually used to give added dimension to a main character, by adding a relationship with this character.

a subplot character or minor character who helps to raise the stakes for the main protagonist, or who reflects the same problems or issues of the protagonist, while providing texture or dimensionality to the setting.

A character that plays a part in the plot but is not major

I asked because I needed some easy definitions when adding characters to games with many playable, but not valuable to the plot line characters.
Top PM EatsSweets
Posted 14 year(s) ago Re: # 7417

CaptainBrain


CaptainBrain Avatar
2 Stars
Head Admin
Joined on 08-02-10
Posts 142

The best way i see solving the sub vs Supporting is with a couple of examples.

I will use Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood as an example:

I would classify Colonel Mustang as a Supporting Character yet I would classify the Fuehrer's "wife" as a sub-character.

Colonel mustang: A long-time reoccurring character who made multiple impacts to the plot.

Mrs. Bradly: A very small role but who has made at least one moderate contribution to the overall story.

So as recap, I would say the difference between sub and Supporting is overall contribution level.

An extra classify as a COTD/ one liner etc.

As for extra long runners (Bleach, one Piece, etc). We may need to divide those shows into "arcs". Looking something like this Franchise-Series-Arc. Where all characters appear in the series but not in an arc.
Top PM CaptainBrain
Posted 14 year(s) ago Re: # 7418

EatsSweets
Page of Void

EatsSweets Avatar
2 Stars

Joined on 05-22-11
Posts 107

I think I understand the difference now. Thanks for the help!
Top PM EatsSweets
Posted 14 year(s) ago Re: # 7419

Rei
ダメ人間

Rei Avatar
10 Stars
Head Admin
Joined on 05-24-07
Posts 2102

Thanks for the examples CaptainBrain!

Seems like the right set of Roles for now. I've give some thought to how we could break series into Arcs. Easiest way might be labeling them "Title - Arc" then assigning it to the franchise. Then we'd need some way of ordering them.
[Image]

私は日本語を少し読むと書くをできます。あなたも?

[Image]
Top PM Rei
Posted 14 year(s) ago Re: # 7463

Kyareshi
The Plotmeister

Kyareshi Avatar
10 Stars

Joined on 01-08-09
Posts 940

I would actually object to "nakama". If you'll pardon me saying so, it does seem more nerdy than it needs to be. "Friends" should be just fine.
[Image]
Top PM Kyareshi
Posted 13 year(s) ago Re: # 10389

ExcelCore



1 Stars

Joined on 09-14-11
Posts 5

Well, we have neither "friends" nor "Nakama". Furthermore, why do we have both protagonist AND main character? They are the same thing right?
Top PM ExcelCore
Post Reply